- Argument‹2 of 2
People who were isolated can now find others in the same situation
The argument
A second argument for this position concerns people whose circumstances are uncommon enough that nobody nearby shares them. Proponents point out that for most of human history a person's available conversation was set by geography: whoever lived within reach was the whole of the pool. For anyone with a rare illness, an unusual occupation, a minority belief, a difficult family situation or an identity not shared locally, this meant there was often nobody to talk to who understood the thing that mattered most, and the resulting isolation was not a shortage of company but a shortage of recognition. Networks that let people find each other by interest rather than by location dissolve that constraint. On this account the significant feature is not the size of the audience but the ability to search it: a condition that affects very few people in any one town affects a large number across a population, and a medium that lets those people assemble turns an isolating circumstance into an ordinary one. Proponents argue that the value of this is hard to overstate for the people concerned, since the relevant good is not entertainment or information but the discovery that one's situation is intelligible to someone else. The position also notes a second gain that follows from the first. Groups formed this way accumulate practical knowledge that no local source had: what to ask a doctor, how a procedure actually went for someone who had it, which difficulties pass and which do not. That knowledge was previously held only by professionals who met such people one at a time, or by nobody at all. Proponents conclude that a medium which converts scattered individuals into a community capable of helping its own members has improved communication in a way the older arrangement could not have matched.
Premises
Counter-arguments
The standard objection is that the same mechanism assembles people around harmful commitments as readily as around illness or rare interests, and with the same efficiency. A medium that lets a person with an uncommon diagnosis find others like them also lets a person with a destructive conviction find a receptive audience, and the sorting that supplies recognition also supplies reinforcement. Critics add that groups formed by shared circumstance tend to confirm their members rather than test them, so the practical knowledge accumulated can be unreliable in exactly the cases where being wrong is most costly.
Rejecting the premises
[Rejecting P1] Critics note that association by interest predates these networks in correspondence circles, learned societies and support groups, so geography was never the whole of the constraint. [Rejecting P2] Efficient sorting by shared circumstance assembles harmful commitments as readily as benign ones, so the mechanism cannot be credited only with its good cases. [Rejecting P3] Groups formed around a shared situation tend to confirm their members rather than test them, which makes the knowledge they accumulate unreliable where accuracy matters most. [Rejecting C] Ending isolation for some while reinforcing harmful conviction in others does not establish an overall improvement in communication.