- Question
Should Cinco de Mayo be celebrated in the USA?
Should Cinco de Mayo be celebrated in the United States? This entry sets out the two positions on the question — that it should be celebrated, and that it should not — touching on heritage, commercialisation and cultural appropriation.
Position 1 of 2
Read this position →Yes, Cinco de Mayo should be celebrated in the USA
This position holds that marking Cinco de Mayo in the United States is a legitimate acknowledgement of Mexican heritage and of Mexican American communities, and that shared public festivity is one of the ways a diverse society recognises the cultures within it.
Position 2 of 2
Read this position →No, Cinco de Mayo should not be celebrated in the USA
This position holds that the American version of Cinco de Mayo has become a commercial drinking occasion detached from the heritage it claims to honour, and that celebrating it in that form invites caricature rather than respect for Mexican culture.