Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question

Should Cinco de Mayo be celebrated in the USA?

Should Cinco de Mayo be celebrated in the United States? This entry sets out the two positions on the question — that it should be celebrated, and that it should not — touching on heritage, commercialisation and cultural appropriation.

Position 1 of 2
Read this position →

Yes, Cinco de Mayo should be celebrated in the USA

This position holds that marking Cinco de Mayo in the United States is a legitimate acknowledgement of Mexican heritage and of Mexican American communities, and that shared public festivity is one of the ways a diverse society recognises the cultures within it.

Position 2 of 2
Read this position →

No, Cinco de Mayo should not be celebrated in the USA

This position holds that the American version of Cinco de Mayo has become a commercial drinking occasion detached from the heritage it claims to honour, and that celebrating it in that form invites caricature rather than respect for Mexican culture.