Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question

Should men-only private members' clubs still exist?

Do men-only private members' clubs still have a place? This entry sets out the two positions on the question — that such clubs should be allowed to exist, and that they should not — weighing free association against exclusion.

Position 1 of 2
Read this position →

Yes, men-only private members' clubs should exist

This position holds that people may associate privately with whom they choose. On this view a club formed and funded by its own members, conferring no public office or service, may set its own membership, and single-sex company has a value of its own.

Position 2 of 2
Read this position →

No, men-only private members' clubs should not exist

This position holds that such clubs should not continue. On this view they are where influence and business are exchanged, so excluding women withholds opportunity rather than company, and their rules state formally who is counted as a peer.