Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
What did Snape mean by 'Always' when speaking to Dumbledor in 'Harry Potter and the Deathy Hallows'?
Position2 of 2

Snape 'always' loved Lily Potter - his statement has nothing to do with Harry himself

There are many moments in the Harry Potter books where Snape expresses resentment towards Harry as a character due to his physical similarity to his father. Dumbledore asking 'after all this time?' is a result of his surprise that Snape's patronus is still a doe - indicating that Snape still loves Lily. His response of 'always' therefore shows that his love for Lily is eternal, not that he has been hiding his love for Harry.

Supporting arguments · 0

No arguments are documented for this position yet.