Positions
2,930 distinct stances on questions in the encyclopedia. Each position aggregates the strongest supporting arguments.
- Yes, Catalonia should become independentPosition 1 on Should Catalonia become independent?This position holds that Catalonia should become independent from Spain. It argues Catalans have a right to self-government denied by Madrid, that the region is culturally and linguistically distinct, and that — as a major net contributor to Spain — it could thrive on its own.
- Yes, catcalling is harassmentPosition 1 on Is catcalling harassment?
- Yes, cell phones increase the risk of cancer.Position 1 on Do cell phones cause cancer?This position holds that cell phones increase the risk of cancer. It argues that there is enough evidence to link the two — that cancer incidence correlates with phone use, that phone radiation can raise the chance of brain tumours, and that phone companies push reassuring bad science.
- Yes, CFS/ME is a real illnessPosition 1 on Is Chronic fatigue syndrome (ME) a real illness?This position holds that Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME) is a real illness. It argues that the condition affects millions worldwide, is recognised by bodies such as the WHO, is increasingly supported by biological evidence including post-exertional malaise, and causes severe, documented suffering.
- Yes, charisma influences political campaignsPosition 1 on Does charisma influence political campaigns?
- Yes, cheating is wrongPosition 1 on Should you confess to cheating after a one night stand?This position holds that you should confess to cheating after a one-night stand, because cheating is wrong and a breach of trust. It argues that honesty and accountability matter — and that concealing a betrayal can violate a partner's trust even more deeply than the act itself.
- Yes, cheerleading is a sportPosition 1 on Is cheerleading a sport?
- Yes, chess is a sportPosition 1 on Is chess a sport?This position holds that chess is a sport. It argues that competitive chess is trained for much as athletics is — years of coached study, daily preparation, opponent analysis — and that elite players even condition their bodies, since fitness shapes performance over a gruelling game.
- Yes, childhood experiences determine behavior later in lifePosition 1 on Do childhood experiences determine behavior in later life?This position holds that childhood experiences determine adult behaviour. It argues that early life encodes how a person behaves later — that a broken family breeds unhealthy relationships, that childhood lessons form one's worldview, and that early trauma leaves lasting interpersonal difficulties.
- Yes, childhood experiences shape our personalitiesPosition 1 on Do childhood experiences determine our adult personalities?For better or worse, every adult lived through some sort of trauma their childhood. More often than not, the quality of one's childhood impacts one's adult life in terms of relationships, mental health, and how one sees the world.
- Yes, children should be homeschooledPosition 1 on Should children be homeschooled?This position holds that children should be homeschooled. It argues that home education can deliver higher-quality, more individual teaching, shields children from the negative environment of conventional schools, and strengthens the bond between parent and child.
- Yes, children should be paid to go to schoolPosition 1 on Should children be paid to go to school?
- Yes, China will become the next superpowerPosition 2 on Will China Become the next Super Power?This position holds that China will become the next superpower. It argues that China's exponential growth will overtake the stagnating powers of the 20th century, that it will replicate Western infrastructure, and that it will reshape the global order, challenging democracy as it rises.
- Yes, China's rise will be peacefulPosition 1 on Will China's rise as a global superpower be peaceful?This position holds that China's rise as a superpower will be peaceful. It argues China has too much to lose from conflict with the West, that its economy is deeply interconnected globally, that it already leads in many fields, and that it benefits from the rules-based order.
- Yes, churches should pay taxesPosition 1 on Should churches pay taxes?This position holds that churches should pay taxes. It argues that their tax-exempt status actually threatens religious freedom and breeds injustice, that taxing them would reflect modern values, and that any church not genuinely serving the common good has no claim to exemption.
- Yes, Cinco de Mayo should be celebrated in the USAPosition 1 on Should Cinco de Mayo be celebrated in the USA?
- Yes, cinema is artPosition 1 on Is cinema art?Cinema is an art form just like any other. It takes creativity and an artistic mind to craft a film; from lighting to camera angles to special effects, costumes, and more, cinematography is by its very definition the art of making film. Without any of these artistic processes, there can be no film.
- Yes, cinema is deadPosition 1 on Is cinema dead?
- Yes, cities can survive permanent work from homePosition 1 on Will cities survive now that work from home is becoming permanent?
- Yes, cleanliness drives should be incentivized to encourage people in IndiaPosition 1 on Should cleanliness drives be incentivized to encourage people in India?
- Yes, climate change is realPosition 1 on Is climate change real?This position holds that climate change is real and driven by human carbon emissions. It argues that the science is clear and the evidence overwhelming — that climate models have proven accurate, that only human emissions explain the warming, and that even oil companies long knew it was real.
- Yes, college education is worth itPosition 1 on Is college education worth it?This position holds that college education is worth it. It argues a degree opens career doors and higher-paid work, makes financial sense over a lifetime, teaches interpersonal skills and how to learn, and brings intangible benefits that improve quality of life.
- Yes, colleges should end legacy admissionsPosition 1 on Should colleges end legacy admissions?Legacy admissions preferences should be ended immediately. They perpetuate harm towards minority students, students of lower-income, and lesser means. They give more privilege to those already privileged and reduce college admissions into unethical financial transactions.
- Yes, comic books should be political.Position 1 on Should comics be political?This position holds that comic books should be political. It argues that, though fictional, comics are grounded in reality, and that politics is an unavoidable part of life — that engaging with it, as the X-Men long have, makes comics more relatable and meaningful, not less.
- Yes, comma usage should be universalPosition 1 on Should comma usage be universal?Comma usage is a unifying standard for language, and inconsistencies detract from the meaning of a sentence. Commas used at a whim are misplaced in academia and formal writing, but they also lead to immense miscommunication in everyday life.
- Yes, communism could be viable in the USAPosition 1 on Is communism viable in the USA?This position holds that communism could be viable in the United States. It argues that American capitalism allows an unjust distribution of wealth that damages society, and that a communist system — by protecting people against job insecurity — could offer a fairer alternative.
- Yes, conditionally- people have the right to choose where they live based on heritage or culturePosition 2 on Should people be able to choose what country to live in?Passports cannot be handed out indiscriminately, but those with a blood or ancestral connection to a country should not have their right to citizenship obstructed. Jus Sanguinis, or citizenship of descent, is commonplace is many countries, but rarely goes far enough- it should be extended to the capability of nations such as Ireland or Italy.
- Yes, confederate monuments should be removedPosition 1 on Should confederate monuments be removed?This position holds that Confederate monuments should be removed. It argues that the statues represent and celebrate slavery and a painful history of abuse, and that the South does not need them to honour its culture — better, less divisive symbols of Southern pride are available.
- Yes, conversion therapy works to alter sexual orientationPosition 1 on Does conversion therapy work to alter sexual orientation?
- Yes, coronavirus is aggravating IslamophobiaPosition 1 on Is coronavirus aggravating Islamophobia in India?This position holds that coronavirus is aggravating Islamophobia in India. It argues that the outbreak has inflamed tensions raised by the Delhi riots, that government policies set the scene for prejudice to grow, and that a Muslim gathering has been scapegoated for spreading the virus.
- Yes, corporal punishment is goodPosition 1 on Should corporal punishment be allowed?This position holds that corporal punishment is good. It argues that, administered correctly, it is a powerful and easily applied deterrent against crime and misbehaviour — and that some people respond to nothing else, making physical punishment uniquely effective in those cases.
- Yes, corporations should have moral responsibilityPosition 2 on Should corporations have "moral responsibility"?Corporations are conversible agents. Their message can be different from that of the individuals that make up the corporation. They also erode individuality. Therefore, corporations must have defined morals to fill the ethical space left by the individual.
- Yes, cosmetic surgery should be covered by health insurancePosition 1 on Should cosmetic surgey be covered by health insurance?
- Yes, countries should accept immigrantsPosition 1 on Should countries accept immigrants?Immigrants fill niches in the labor market, work hard to build a better life for themselves, and ultimately boost the host country's economy. Immigrants benefit the high-tech and biotech industries too. They also contribute to education and philanthropy. There are purely philosophical cases for immigration as well, such as the egalitarian case and the libertarian case.
- Yes, Covid immunity passports will unlock travelPosition 1 on Can Covid immunity passports unlock travel?
- Yes, Covid-19 has turned the clock back on women's equalityPosition 1 on Has Covid-19 turned the clock back on women's equality?This position holds that Covid-19 set back women's equality. Its argument is that the pandemic hit women hardest on both sides of the labour market — disproportionately costing them jobs in shut-down sectors like hospitality, while exposing them disproportionately on the essential-worker front line.
- Yes, Covid-19 is making airplane passengers more unrulyPosition 1 on Is Covid-19 making airplane passengers more unruly?
- Yes, creationism should be taught in schoolsPosition 1 on Should creationism be taught in schools?This position holds that creationism should be taught in schools in some capacity. It argues schools cannot simply ignore it, that it fits within philosophy or religion courses, that it need not conflict with evolution, and that it belongs alongside other theories.
- Yes, cursive should be taught in schoolsPosition 1 on Should cursive be taught in schools?Cursive is an art form and a skill, and there is value in making sure children have a basic knowledge of certain skills. In addition, cursive has connections to many forms of learning.
- Yes, cyberbullying should be a crimePosition 1 on Should cyberbullying be a crime?
- Yes, data rights are human rightsPosition 1 on Are data rights human rights?Just like privacy is a human right, personal data should be considered private and only given out at the user's discretion. No one would expect it to be okay to steal someone's social security number, for example, so why is personal data any different? Data rights are human rights because we have a right to keep our personal lives and information private.
- Yes, democracy in America is under threatPosition 1 on Is democracy in America under threat?Recent events, including the 2020 Presidential Election and how the Covid-19 pandemic has been handled, prove that democracy in America is on the decline. Trump and others have attacked democracy's very core, and have managed to manipulate it to serve their own ends. When democracy fails to keep our government in check, then it is time to admit that it is no longer working. The American people need to stop being complacent and fight to eliminate all threats to democracy, or come up with something new.
- Yes, despite that Western countries and non-Western countries perceive human rights differentlyPosition 2 on Does the West still value human rights in light of its dismissal of Khashoggi's death?This position holds that the West still values human rights, even though Western and non-Western countries understand them differently. It argues that human rights express particular Western norms, and that different countries set different goals — so divergence is not the same as abandonment.
- Yes, destruction of the environment caused the coronavirus pandemicPosition 1 on Is human destruction of nature responsible for COVID-19?This position holds that human destruction of nature caused the coronavirus pandemic. It argues that environmental devastation and practices such as eating wild meat push humans and animals together, and that without this damage the COVID-19 outbreak would not have occurred.
- Yes, Dickens was a social progressivePosition 1 on Was Charles Dickens a social progressive?Dickens' focus in his novels and journalism was often on issues affecting the growing Victorian working classes, such as poor working conditions and an unjust legal system. Through this campaigning, he was able to attract significant public attention and helped improve living conditions for Londoners living in slums.
- Yes, dictatorships are effetive for developmentPosition 1 on Are dictatorships effective for development?
- Yes, digital cinema has destroyed realismPosition 1 on Has digital cinema destroyed realism?
- Yes, direct democracy is superiorPosition 1 on Is direct democracy superior to representative democracy?This position holds that direct democracy is superior to representative democracy. It argues that letting citizens vote directly best reflects the people's will — encouraging open participation, fostering civic responsibility, and giving people more control over their own lives.
- Yes, Disney movies are racistPosition 1 on Are Walt Disney Animation Studios' movies racist?Disney movies are racist because they fail to represent other cultures from the cultures' own perspective. They white-wash characters, take creative liberties with cultural stories and themes, and appropriate culture to serve their own ends.
- Yes, Donald Trump is a good presidentPosition 1 on Has Donald Trump been a good president?This position holds that Donald Trump has been a good president. Its arguments point to his record over four years: standing up for American interests abroad, keeping his campaign promises, and what supporters regard as his successful management of the economy.