Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Do social media influencers have a positive impact?
Position‹2 of 3›
Social media influencers have a positive impact
Argument1 of 2›

Direct access to an audience broke a gate that was never open to most people

The argument

Proponents of this position begin from what the arrangement replaced. For most of the history of mass communication, reaching a large audience required the approval of a small number of institutions, and those institutions commissioned people who resembled the people already commissioned. Whole subjects went uncovered because no commissioner thought there was an audience, and whole categories of person were absent from the screen for reasons that had nothing to do with whether anyone wanted to hear from them. The argument is that direct access removed the approval step, and that the consequences have been largely good for the people formerly excluded. Audiences turned out to exist for a great deal that commissioners had judged unviable: specific illnesses, particular kinds of craft and repair, minority languages, unglamorous occupations explained by the people who do them, and the ordinary business of managing a life with a condition that few others understand. Proponents emphasise that this is not only about representation, since the practical content is often information that was genuinely unavailable elsewhere, supplied by someone with first hand experience rather than by a researcher with an afternoon. Holders of the view argue that the resulting livelihoods matter too. The arrangement lets people earn from an audience they built themselves, without a commission, a contract or a gatekeeper, which is a route into paid creative work for people who would never have been let through the old door. They accept that the model has characteristic failures and argue that these should be weighed against the right comparison, which is not an ideal media system but the one that preceded it, where the same failures existed with a narrower set of beneficiaries and no way in for anyone else.

Premises

[P1]Reaching a large audience formerly required approval from a small number of institutions that commissioned people resembling those already commissioned. [P2] Direct access removed that approval step, and audiences proved to exist for subjects and people those institutions had judged unviable. [P3] The arrangement also lets people earn from an audience they built themselves, without a commission or a gatekeeper. [C] Influencers have had a positive impact by opening access to audiences for people and subjects previously excluded.

Counter-arguments

Critics accept the account of the old gatekeepers and argue that the gate did not disappear so much as move. What now determines who is seen is a set of ranking systems owned by a few companies, which are less accountable than editors and whose criteria are not published, and the resulting hierarchy is at least as steep as the one it replaced. They also note that earning from an audience is available to very few, that the failures of the model fall on audiences rather than on the people profiting, and that representation gained is not obviously worth a general decline in the reliability of what circulates.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P2] The approval step was replaced rather than removed, since ranking systems owned by a few companies now determine what is seen, with criteria that are neither published nor accountable. [Rejecting P3] Earning a living this way is available to a very small minority, so the premise describes an opportunity that is formal rather than real for most of those it is said to benefit. [Rejecting C] Wider access is a real gain that still has to be weighed against costs the argument does not count, including who bears the risk when what circulates is unreliable.