- Question
Do social media influencers have a positive impact?
Are social media influencers a force for good or ill? This entry maps the positions on the question — that influencers have a negative impact, that they have a positive one, and that their impact is a mix of both.
Social media influencers have a negative impact
Proponents of this position argue that the influencer relationship is advertising disguised as friendship, that it rewards whatever holds attention rather than whatever is true, and that it sets standards of appearance and wealth that audiences measure themselves against.
Social media influencers have a positive impact
On this view influencers broke the hold of a few institutions on what could be said and shown, opening audiences to people who were never going to be commissioned, and giving practical knowledge and livelihoods to those outside established channels.
Social media influencers have both a positive and negative impact
This position holds that the influencer is a channel rather than a force with a single direction. What comes through depends on who is using it and how, so the useful questions are about particular practices rather than about influencers as a class.