Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question

What is the best drug regulation system?

What makes for the best system of drug regulation? This entry maps the contending priorities — pharmacovigilance, the regulation of clinical trials, and the inspection of standards in drug development and manufacture.

Position 1 of 3
Read this position →

Pharmacovigilance

Proponents argue that a regulator learns most about a medicine after it is licensed, when it meets a population far larger and more varied than any trial, so the system should be built to collect and act on reports of harm in ordinary use.

Position 2 of 3
Read this position →

Regulating clinical trials

This position puts the weight of regulation before approval, on the design and conduct of trials, holding that a decision about whether a medicine works and is safe can only be as sound as the evidence gathered to support it.

Position 3 of 3
Read this position →

Inspecting and maintaining standards of drug development and manufacture

On this view the best system concentrates on how medicines are actually made, inspecting facilities, tracing supply chains and enforcing manufacturing standards, on the grounds that an approved drug is only as good as the batch that reaches the patient.