Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Should genetically modifying babies be legal?
Position2 of 2

No, genetically modifying babies should not be legal

This position holds that genetically modifying babies should not be legal. It argues the procedure carries serious safety risks for both mother and child, that most scientists consider it a bad idea, and that it could give rise to a genetic caste system dividing society.

Supporting arguments · 3

  1. Genetically modifying babies would create a new caste system
    If some members of our society receive genetic enhancements, those who are not genetically enhanced will fall into a lower class.
  2. The majority of scientists think that this is a bad idea
    We should heed the voices of scientific experts warning against this procedure's possible drawbacks.
  3. The practice holds serious safety risks for the mother and baby
    Do the potential benefits of this procedure justify risks to the health of mother and baby?