Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Is a world without any borders a good idea?
Position2 of 2

No, we should keep our borders

Borders protect nation-states and ensure that governments can take care of their citizens. The cultural and economic gains possible from open borders are not worth the safety and economic risks that will occur if people freely migrate between nation-states.

Supporting arguments · 4

  1. Opening borders is like removing the doors from your home
    When we put locks on our doors and fences around our home, we do so with the intention of protecting what we have created. A country has a culture that supports what it created, and borders help to protect that.
  2. Getting rid of borders would destroy culture
    Borders maintain cultural heritages that stretch back through history, and cultures are worth protecting. Eliminating borders would mean losing cultural identity and heritage.
  3. Open borders will endanger citizens' safety
    There are many criminals and terrorists in other countries who would move to richer countries if they could. Abolishing borders would threaten countries' national security.
  4. Countries cannot economically or politically sustain open borders
    Opening all borders would result in everyone migrating to richer, safer countries. These countries do not have the societal infrastructure to sustain the influx of immigrants.