Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Is it okay to punch Nazis?
Position‹3 of 3

Whether it is OK to punch Nazis or not doesn't fit in to the "yes or no" framework

This position holds that whether it is okay to punch Nazis cannot be answered with a simple yes or no. It argues that any justification for violence must always be contextualised — the appropriateness of the act depending on the actual circumstances rather than a blanket rule.

Supporting arguments · 1

  1. The appropriateness of punching a Nazi is determined by actual circumstances
    Because violence doesn't work in predictable ways, there is no universal answer about whether it is okay to punch a Nazi. The consequences of violence should be weighted against the distinct threat of harm posed by the specific Nazi in question. One would have to look at the circumstances of the situation, such as deciding if there is an immediate risk of supporters retaliating.