- Position1 of 3›
Yes, an unamendable constitution is undemocratic
A constitution is supposed to reflect the values of a society at a given time. An unamendable constitution binds future generations to past values, thereby reducing their democratic influence.
Supporting arguments · 4
- Democracy to necrocracyForcing future generations to be governed by the 'dead hand' of their founding fathers drags a democracy into a necrocracy.
- The judicial branch holds all the powerThe judicial branch becomes a legislative gatekeeper by effectively interpreting a dated constitution and applying that interpretation to modern legislation.
- Increased instabilityWhen the electorate cannot achieve constitutional reform through democratic means, they are more likely to pursue violent means of political change.
- Generates apathyReducing constituents' democratic powers generates apathy and reduced democratic participation.