Positions
2,930 distinct stances on questions in the encyclopedia. Each position aggregates the strongest supporting arguments.
- Yes, the sale of human organs should be legalizedPosition 1 on Should the sale of human organs be legalised
- Yes, the Salem Witch Trials were justifiedPosition 1 on Were the Salem Witch Trials justified?
- Yes, the Simpsons are racistPosition 1 on Are The Simpsons racist?
- Yes, the South African constitution is a model for the rest of the worldPosition 1 on Is the South African constitution a model constitution for the rest of the world?
- Yes, the Star Trek Lower Decks is a cannonPosition 1 on Was the Star Trek Lower Decks a cannon?
- Yes, the subconscious mind creates realityPosition 1 on Does the subconscious mind create reality?This position holds that the subconscious mind shapes reality, our beliefs and thoughts continuously moulding our experience. It argues that thoughts cause real neurochemical change — as the placebo effect shows — and that the beliefs we hold shape who we become and the lives we lead.
- Yes, the theory of evolution is correctPosition 1 on Is the theory of evolution by natural selection correct?The theory is correct because it is supported by an abundance of historical and scientific data. It is also explanatorily successful and the bedrock of biology. In a nutshell, the theory says that all living organisms have emerged with variations from species that existed before them. This evolution happened through a phenomenon called natural selection. Natural selection can be described as "survival of the fittest" since the "fittest" organisms—the ones that are most cut out for their environment—are the ones that have the highest rate of reproduction and the greatest chance of passing on their best traits. A change in environment will spark a gradual change in those traits that help with survival.
- Yes, the TikTok security threat is realPosition 1 on Is the TikTok security threat real?
- Yes, the top stopped spinning at the end of InceptionPosition 1 on Did the top stop spinning in the end of Inception?
- Yes, the Trump Administration has responded well to the CoronavirusPosition 1 on Has the Trump administration responded well to COVID-19?The actions taken by the Administration have shown leadership, have calmed the public and the markets, and have shown good decision making in a difficult situation.
- Yes, the U.S should have year-round educationPosition 1 on Should the U.S. mandate year-round education?This position holds that the US should mandate year-round education. It argues that a continuous schedule helps students retain what they learn — avoiding the summer 'slide' — and that it would help close the achievement gap for minority students and students with disabilities.
- Yes, the UK should charge for access to its higher education institutions.Position 2 on Should UK students be charged university fees?Others believe that charging for education is the only certain way we can guarantee a constant source of funding for universities, and that it is fairer to only charge those who use the service for accessing it.
- Yes, the UK should have remained in the EUPosition 1 on Should the UK have remained in the EU?This position holds that the UK should have remained in the European Union. It argues that the world needs more international cooperation, not less, that interdependence between nations reduces the scope for war, and that leaving needlessly reopened tensions over the Irish border.
- Yes, the UN leader Dag Hammarskjold was murderedPosition 1 on Was UN leader Dag Hammarskjold murdered?
- Yes, the universal norm of human rights still holds strong in the WestPosition 1 on Does the West still value human rights in light of its dismissal of Khashoggi's death?This position holds that the universal norm of human rights still holds strong in the West, despite controversies. It points to the West's long postwar record — confronting the Axis, founding the United Nations — and to Western organisations that aid those in need worldwide.
- Yes, the US and Chinese economies could 'decouple'Position 1 on Could the US and Chinese economies really 'decouple'?
- Yes, the US is about to split the InternetPosition 1 on Is the US about to split the internet?
- Yes, the US should break into smaller nationsPosition 1 on Should the U.S. break up into smaller distinct nations?The differences between the regions and states of the United States have become too stark. America is simply too large to achieve cohesion, and if any real progress is to be made in the country, it must change its thinking and become separate countries. This would afford the sharp regional differences to no longer hinder a federal government. Furthermore, there has long been a states’ rights mentality in the United States, to break down a step further is the logical progression. A situation like the European Union may be favorable.
- Yes, the US should maintain the embargo.Position 1 on Should the US maintain the embargo against Cuba?This position holds that the US should keep its embargo on Cuba. It argues that the Cuban government remains hostile and has never met the conditions for lifting it, and that ending the embargo would economically strengthen a dictatorial regime, effectively endorsing it.
- Yes, the US should recognize Palestine as a statePosition 1 on Should the US recognize Palestine as a state?
- Yes, the wealthy should have to pay more in taxesPosition 1 on Should the wealthy pay more taxes?This position holds that the wealthy should pay more in taxes. It argues that higher taxes on the rich would reduce inequality, that the wealthy benefit most from the structure of society and so owe more back, and that there is a moral obligation to support the less privileged.
- Yes, the weight of fashion models should be policedPosition 1 on Should the weight of fashion models be policed?This position holds that the weight of fashion models should be policed. It argues that doing so creates clear, healthier guidelines for the industry — protecting models from dangerous pressure to be underweight — and that bodies can reasonably set minimum BMI standards for those who model.
- Yes, the wellness industry is racistPosition 1 on Is the wellness industry racist?Yes, the wellness industry is racist because of its underlying systemic racism, lack of accessibility and acknowledgement of Black, Indigenous, and People of Colour (BIPOC).
- Yes, the world has started to take Climate Change seriouslyPosition 1 on Has the world started to take climate change fight seriously?
- Yes, the world would be better without genderPosition 1 on Would the world be better without gender?
- Yes, theocracies have many good pointsPosition 1 on Is theocracy good?This position holds that theocracies have many good points. It argues that grounding government in a shared religion creates unity and stability, removes the need for compromise, and makes for efficient rule — and notes that most major religions envisage a theocracy in their doctrine.
- Yes, theodicies explain that God allows people the free will to commit evilPosition 2 on Do theodicies explain why God allows evil in the world?This position holds that theodicies successfully explain why God allows evil, through the free-will defence. It argues that God grants human beings genuine free will, and that the evil some people commit is the price of that freedom — reconciling a good God with the existence of evil.
- Yes, theodicies explain the existence of an all-powerful, benevolent GodPosition 1 on Do theodicies explain why God allows evil in the world?This position holds that theodicies successfully explain the existence of an all-powerful, benevolent God despite evil. It argues that God is the sole perfect being, and that evil may serve a higher purpose we cannot grasp — so suffering does not contradict a loving, omnipotent creator.
- Yes, there are advantages to being a part of fandom culturePosition 1 on What are the advantages and disadvantages of fandom culture?This position holds that there are real advantages to fandom culture. It argues that a shared love of a topic or celebrity brings people together, creating a strong sense of community and belonging that can also boost participants' confidence and self-esteem.
- Yes, there are advantages to making a company 100% employee-ownedPosition 1 on What are the advantages and disadvantages of companies being 100% employee-owned?This position holds that there are real advantages to making a company fully employee-owned. It argues that employee-owned firms (ESOPs) tend to outperform others by building trust and aligning interests, and that the job security they provide boosts well-being and productivity.
- Yes, there are more than two gendersPosition 1 on Are there more than two genders?Gender expression is not exclusively male and female. There are many forms that reside on a spectrum. This spectrum offers tremendous freedom to transgender persons as well as to people born intersex.
- Yes, there are positives to European colonialismPosition 1 on Were there any positives to European Colonialism?This position argues that European colonialism had positives. It holds that empires were vital in spreading the global norms underpinning the modern economy and way of life, that imperialism effectively created the modern world, and that colonial rule bettered some later post-colonial regimes.
- Yes, there is a social media biasPosition 1 on Is there a social media bias?
- Yes, there is life on VenusPosition 1 on Is there life on Venus?
- Yes, there should be a tax on sugarPosition 1 on Should there be a tax on sugar?This position holds that there should be a tax on sugar. It argues that sugar is unhealthy, addictive and not something the body actually requires to function — so taxing it would curb consumption while generating revenue that can be returned to the community.
- Yes, there should be a world governmentPosition 1 on Should there be a world government?Humans should unite supranationally to form a world government. This will benefit all humanity and allow cooperation on a global scale in science, medicine, technology, and climatic issues. Poverty and hunger would be eradicated. Ressources would be equally distributed.
- Yes, there should be advertisements for prescription drugsPosition 2 on Should there be advertisements for prescription drugs?The range of available medications in the world continues to grow exponentially and even doctors aren't able to keep up with all of them. DTC helps consumers understand their options
- Yes, there should be tests for votingPosition 1 on Should there be a test to vote?This position holds that there should be a test to vote. It argues that requiring voters to demonstrate some understanding of how politics works would make people think more seriously about their choice, reduce uninformed bias, and ultimately benefit the country.
- Yes, there will be enough water in 2050Position 1 on Will there be enough water in 2050?
- Yes, there's too much money in footballPosition 1 on Is there too much money in football?This position holds that there is too much money in football. It argues that commercialisation and advertising have overtaken the game, that working-class fans are being priced out, that players earn millions amid mass poverty, and that the richest clubs leave the poorest unable to compete.
- Yes, they should remain apoliticalPosition 1 on Should the supreme court justices be apolitical?This position holds that Supreme Court justices should remain apolitical. It argues the Constitution's framers, reacting against a Crown-controlled judiciary, deliberately built an independent, impartial court — and that fidelity to that intent requires justices to stay above partisan politics.
- Yes, Tony Blair is a war criminalPosition 2 on Is Tony Blair a war criminal?This position holds that Tony Blair is a war criminal. It argues that he violated international law in taking Britain to war in Iraq — actions blamed for hundreds of thousands of deaths — that others have been tried for lesser crimes, and that he was driven in part by financial greed.
- Yes, Tony died in the finale of The SopranosPosition 1 on Did Tony die in the finale of The Sopranos?
- Yes, torture can be justifiedPosition 1 on Is torture ever justified?This position holds that torture can sometimes be justified. Its core argument is consequentialist — that the end can justify the means — contending that torture may extract highly valuable information capable of saving many lives, and that this can outweigh the harm done to the individual.
- Yes, tourism is beneficial to developing countriesPosition 1 on Is tourism beneficial to developing countries?This position holds that tourism benefits developing countries. It argues tourism pulls in valuable revenue, raises the overall quality of life, and fosters independence among citizens—including greater financial independence for women—helping local economies grow and diversify.
- Yes, toys should be genderedPosition 1 on Should children's toys be gendered?This position holds that children's toys should be gendered. It argues that boys and girls differ, so gender-specific toys simply cater to their distinct preferences — and that abolishing gendered toys would undermine traditional gender roles and harm the toy industry.
- Yes, transgender children and adolescents should medically transitionPosition 1 on Should transgender children medically transition?If a transgender child or adolescent wants to medically transition, and they are insistent and persistent about their gender identity for an extended period of time, they should medically transition.
- Yes, Trump is a person devoid of good characterPosition 1 on Is Trump is a person devoid of good character?
- Yes, Twitter was correct to fact check TrumpPosition 1 on Was Twitter correct in fact checking Trump?Twitter did the right thing to fact check the President of the United States. Twitter is a platform with enormous reach, and it is critical that information, especially from those in power, is factual and correct.
- Yes, UBI is a good ideaPosition 2 on Is Universal Basic Income a good idea?This position holds that Universal Basic Income is a good idea. It argues that UBI does not reduce incentives to work, that it enables everyone to meet their basic needs and participate more fully in society, and that it is simpler to administer than existing forms of welfare.