- Argument1 of 2›
Influencers are a channel, and a channel takes the character of its use
The argument
Proponents of this position argue that the two confident answers are both generalising from a sample. The category covers a practitioner explaining their trade, a person documenting an illness so that others recognise it, someone reviewing tools they actually use, and alongside them accounts selling remedies that do not work and selling a standard of appearance that nobody meets. These have almost nothing in common except the mechanism by which they reach an audience. A verdict on the mechanism, on this account, is being asked to carry a verdict on everything done with it. The argument is that the mechanism itself is close to neutral and that the determining factors are elsewhere: what is being communicated, whether the person has any standing to communicate it, how the money works, and how young and how isolated the audience is. Proponents note that the same single account routinely does good and harm in the same week, giving someone information they could not otherwise get and selling them something they do not need. If a single account is mixed, they argue, a verdict on the whole class is unlikely to be available. Holders of the position present this as a claim about the shape of the question rather than a refusal to judge. They are willing to say that undisclosed payment is bad, that medical advice from the unqualified is dangerous, and that advertising aimed at children through personal attachment is objectionable. What they decline is the move from those judgements to a verdict on influencers as such, because the same findings would condemn or vindicate large parts of publishing, broadcasting and ordinary commerce depending on which examples were chosen.
Premises
Counter-arguments
Critics on both sides argue that this is true of any technology and therefore says little. Every medium carries good and bad uses, they note, and the interesting question is what a medium does on balance and what it makes more likely, which this position declines to answer. They add that neutrality claims tend to favour whatever is already in place: if the model's incentives reliably reward some harms, calling the channel neutral obscures where the pressure comes from. Others argue the position is not really a third view but a restatement of the question.
Rejecting the premises
[Rejecting P2] A mechanism can be other than neutral by making some uses easier and more profitable than others, which is precisely what critics of the model claim about its incentives. [Rejecting P3] Mixed individual cases are compatible with a clear balance across the class, which is what a verdict on the class asks about. [Rejecting C] Declining to assess the balance leaves the question unanswered rather than answered in a third way, since both rival positions already accept that good and bad cases exist.