Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Do social media influencers have a positive impact?
Position‹3 of 3
Social media influencers have both a positive and negative impact
Argument‹2 of 2

The same features produce the benefits and the harms

The argument

A second argument offered for this position is stronger than the appeal to variety, and proponents regard it as the position's real case. The features that make the arrangement valuable are the same features that make it dangerous, which means the good and the bad cannot be separated and a one directional verdict is not available. They set the pairs out directly. There is no gatekeeper, which is why people formerly excluded can reach an audience, and also why no one checks a claim before it reaches that audience. The relationship is personal, which is why the information lands and is acted on, and also why a recommendation evades the defences the audience would bring to an advertisement. Anyone can speak from experience, which is why a person managing an unusual condition can help others in the same position, and also why someone with no qualifications can be heard on the same subject in the same register. The audience can answer back, which supplies correction and also means the loudest reply wins. Holders of the view draw the conclusion carefully. They are not saying the harms and benefits are equal, which would be a claim nobody can support, but that they are produced by one structure and so cannot be traded off independently. Removing the harm by introducing gatekeepers, credential requirements or a ban on personal recommendation would remove the benefit in the same motion. On this account the question of whether influencers have a positive impact is less useful than the question of which specific harms can be mitigated without destroying the access that produced the gains, and that question has different answers for different harms.

Premises

[P1]The absence of a gatekeeper produces both wider access for the previously excluded and the absence of any check before a claim reaches an audience. [P2] The personal character of the relationship both makes information land and strips the audience of the defences it would bring to advertising. [P3] Measures that would remove these harms, such as gatekeeping or credential requirements, would remove the corresponding benefits in the same motion. [C] The benefits and harms are produced by one structure, so no one directional verdict on influencers is available.

Counter-arguments

Critics argue that the pairing is not as tight as claimed. Many proposed remedies target one side only, since enforcing disclosure of payment, restricting advertising to children, and treating unqualified medical claims as a regulatory matter would each leave open access intact. They also note that structures with mixed effects are assessed on balance all the time, including in medicine and in law, so the inseparability of good and bad consequences does not usually stop anyone reaching a verdict. Others argue that the position understates how unevenly the benefits and harms are distributed.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P2] The personal register can be retained while the commercial element is marked, since disclosure requirements separate the relationship from the advertisement without abolishing either. [Rejecting P3] Several remedies target one side only, including enforced disclosure of payment and restrictions on advertising to children, and these leave open access intact. [Rejecting C] Structures with inseparably mixed effects are routinely assessed on balance, so inseparability does not show that no verdict is available.