Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Is torture ever justified?
Position2 of 2

No, torture cannot be justified

This position holds that torture can never be justified. It argues that torture is a fundamental violation of human rights and dignity, that it is unreliable and simply does not work, and that intelligence extracted under torture is inadmissible and tainted in any case.

Supporting arguments · 3

  1. Torture doesn't work
    Torture warps the mind and information said can be false because of it.
  2. Torture undermines human rights and dignity
    It is unacceptable to undermine human rights in the way that torture does.
  3. Torture renders intelligence as inadmissible in court settings