Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Should Scotland seek independence?
Position2 of 3

Scotland should remain in the UK

The union between Scotland, England, Wales, and Northern Ireland is greater than the sum of its parts. Their shared history and fate is a strength and not a weakness.

Supporting arguments · 3

  1. Scotland is financially entangled with the UK
    If Scotland were to become independent, they would either need to retain the pound sterling or create a new form of currency. Both options risk financial turbulence for the country and are too high a cost for independence.
  2. Scotland would not be able to enter the EU right away
    A fundamental aspect of the present independence debate is Scotland returning to the EU as an independent nation. There is already a list of countries waiting to become members of the EU, and there is no guarantee that Scotland would skip the queue.
  3. An independent Scotland would threaten British identity
    While Scotland offers its own unique identity, it is still deeply tied with a broader British national identity. There are far more similarities than differences between Scotland and the rest of the Union.