Positions
2,930 distinct stances on questions in the encyclopedia. Each position aggregates the strongest supporting arguments.
- Yes, people should be prosecuted for crimes they commit in augmented realityPosition 1 on Should people be prosecuted for crimes they commit in augmented reality?
- Yes, people should switch to electric carsPosition 1 on Should people switch to electric cars for the environment?This position holds that people should switch to electric cars for the environment. It argues that, running on electricity rather than petrol, they cut air and noise pollution and reduce reliance on fossil fuels — a revolutionary technology that would make the world a cleaner, better place.
- Yes, Persuasion presents more ethical dilemmas than ArgumentationPosition 1 on Does Persuasion present more ethical dilemmas than Argumentation?
- Yes, plants are consciousPosition 1 on Are plants conscious?
- Yes, plastic products can be replaced with eco friendly optionsPosition 1 on Can plastic products be replaced with eco friendly options?This position holds that plastic products can be replaced with eco-friendly options. It argues that plastic's environmental harm makes replacement necessary, that a growing range of substitutes now mimics its versatility, and that natural materials such as cellulose can replace uses like packaging.
- Yes, polar bears will become extinct in the futurePosition 1 on Will polar bears become extinct in the future?Polar bears are very sensitive organisms. They can only survive in artic regions of the world like Antarctica. As time passes by, they are in danger of becoming extinct.
- Yes, political correctness harms societyPosition 1 on Does political correctness harm society?This position holds that political correctness harms society, cultivating discord rather than progress. It argues that PC norms stifle free speech, offer only a superficial fix for real inequality, strain everyday relationships, and amount to a new form of prejudice in themselves.
- Yes, polygamy in relationships should be decriminalisedPosition 1 on Should polygamy in relationships be decriminalized?The legalisation of group unions should be afforded to all as we move on from traditional conceptions of love. Marriage equality is changing and desiring to exercise one’s right to marry, irrespective of the number of persons involved, should be allowed by the state.
- Yes, polygraphs should be allowed in courtPosition 1 on Should polygraphs be admissible in court?This position holds that polygraphs should be admissible in court. It argues that lie detectors help determine a subject's truthfulness and often induce confessions, that they are already used elsewhere in law, and that technology should aid the justice system's search for truth.
- Yes, poor management of forests is to blame for the deadly fires in the United StatesPosition 1 on Is poor management of forests to blame for deadly fires in the United States?
- Yes, porn is harmful and misleading and should be banned for minorsPosition 2 on Should pornography be banned for people under 18?Pornography is desensitizing and potentially addictive. People under the age of 18 are not capable of making adult decisions regarding the content they consume and should be protected from harmful images.
- Yes, pornography leads to violence against womenPosition 1 on Does pornography lead to violence against women?
- Yes, preventative war can be justifiedPosition 1 on Can preventive war be justified?
- Yes, prisons should be abolishedPosition 1 on Should prisons be abolished?This position holds that prisons should be abolished. It argues that prisons simply do not work, that private prisons profit from locking people up, and that incarceration is immoral — and that a more ethical system would reintegrate offenders into society as citizens instead.
- Yes, private firms will win the race to VenusPosition 1 on Will private firms win the race to Venus?
- Yes, protests are effectivePosition 1 on Are protests effective?
- Yes, psychiatry is a shamPosition 1 on Is psychiatry a sham?
- Yes, psychics are realPosition 1 on Are psychics real?This position holds that psychics and their abilities are real. It points to reports that the CIA once funded a psychic research programme, to claims that some people possess extrasensory perception (ESP), and to the testimony of clients who insist their psychic experiences were genuine.
- Yes, psychopaths can be curedPosition 2 on Can psychopaths be cured?
- Yes, public nudity should be legalPosition 1 on Should public nudity be legal?
- Yes, punishing pedophiles counts as discriminationPosition 1 on Does punishing pedophiles count as discrimination?
- Yes, QAnon is taking over AmericaPosition 1 on Is QAnon taking over America?
- Yes, quarantine is bad for your mental healthPosition 2 on Is spending time quarantined bad for your mental health?This position holds that quarantine is bad for mental health. It argues that isolation from friends and family and reduced social contact cause real harm—fuelling depression and PTSD, straining family relationships, and driving up rates of drug dependency.
- Yes, recessions are always a bad thingPosition 1 on Are recessions always a bad thing?Recessions invariably result in economic hardship, increasing unemployment, reducing consumer spending, and leading to business failures, adversely affecting societies.
- Yes, recycling does work and improves the environmentPosition 1 on Does recycling work?This position holds that recycling works and improves the environment. It argues there is evidence of its benefits, that it has become a normal part of daily life, that it discourages littering, encourages sustainable buying, and helps clean up the environment.
- Yes, religion is detrimental to societyPosition 1 on Is religion detrimental to society?The social institution critiqued by Karl Marx as "the opiate of the masses" is just as harmful as any literal drug, promoting tribalism and permitting atrocities in God's name.
- Yes, religion is the primary factor.Position 1 on Is religion the primary motivation and recruitment behind ISIS?This position holds that religion is the primary motivation behind ISIS and its recruitment. It argues that the group built itself around a Salafist reading of Islam, and that fighters join out of genuine belief in jihad and clear religious goals rather than mainly political ones.
- Yes, religion should be taught in schoolsPosition 1 on Should religion be taught in schools?
- Yes, religion tells us to care for the environmentPosition 2 on Should we care for environment?This position holds that religion commands care for the environment, via the 'stewardship' view: God made humans caretakers of creation, giving them a duty to protect it. It draws on Genesis — Adam and Eve told to 'work it and take care of it' — and on figures like Pope John Paul II.
- Yes, rent caps are a good ideaPosition 1 on Are rent caps a good idea?This position holds that rent caps are a good idea. It argues that capping rents keeps housing affordable for tenants, prevents the displacement of long-standing residents from their neighbourhoods, and helps reduce the political friction that soaring rents can generate in a community.
- Yes, ride-hailing apps are a benefit to societyPosition 1 on Are ride-hailing apps a benefit to society?Ride-hailing apps connect passengers with drivers quickly, safely, and efficiently. Passengers are provided with their driver's ID and car information before their car arrives. Passengers can also share their real-time route and driver details with friends or family which adds more security.
- Yes, rioting can be justifiedPosition 1 on Is rioting ever justified?There are instances where no other action can be taken to ensure that justice is achieved, other avenues for redress have been exhausted, and some form of violence is needed to move governments to action.
- Yes, Salafi Islam is compatiblePosition 1 on Is Salafi Islam compatible with secular Western cultures?
- Yes, school uniforms should be mandatory.Position 1 on Should school uniforms be mandatory?This position holds that school uniforms should be mandatory. It argues they bring many benefits—saving families time and money, making classrooms safer and more equal, reducing distraction, and fostering a shared sense of order and identity among students.
- Yes, schools should be able to ban booksPosition 2 on Should schools be able to ban books?This position holds that schools should be able to ban books. It argues that schools have a responsibility to regulate what children read — keeping out material that promotes hate speech, and shielding young students from content too mature for their age.
- Yes, schools should continue Eurocentric curriculumsPosition 2 on Should schools continue Eurocentric curriculums?This position holds that schools should continue Eurocentric curriculums. It argues that European civilisations form the basis of modern societies, so such an education is crucial to understanding today's world — and that Western curriculums should remain the dominant narrative in Western society.
- Yes, schools should have armed security guardsPosition 1 on Should schools have armed security guards?
- yes, schools should have dress codes to keep everyone focused and appropriatePosition 1 on Should schools have dress codes?
- Yes, scientific research should get more governmental fundingPosition 1 on Should scienific research get more governmental funding?
- Yes, sentient artificial intelligence should have human rightsPosition 1 on Should sentient artificial intelligence have human rights?
- Yes, service can be refused on grounds of religion in all casesPosition 1 on #CakeGate: can you refuse service on the basis of faith?This position holds that service can be refused on religious grounds in all cases. It argues that forcing someone to provide a service against their faith is wrong, that religious freedom is uniquely important, and that creative work like baking a cake is a form of protected expression.
- Yes, sex education should be taught in schoolsPosition 2 on Should sex education be taught in schools?This position holds that sex education should be taught in schools. It argues that school is where children build decision-making skills, that not everyone has access elsewhere, and that good sex education cuts unwanted pregnancies and STDs, eases shame and anxiety, and fosters inclusion.
- Yes, Shakespeare is universal and timeless.Position 1 on Is Shakespeare's writing universal and timeless?This position holds that Shakespeare's writing is universal and timeless. It argues that the depth and beauty of his work let it resonate across the centuries — that he addressed complex societal issues still with us today, and explored rather than argued about his great themes.
- Yes, short films are worth watchingPosition 1 on Are short films worth watching?This position holds that short films are worth watching. It argues they are a powerful way to experience stories, can be made by almost anyone, give a platform to overlooked voices, allow unique and experimental work, and often lead to feature-length films.
- Yes, smart phones are making us smarterPosition 1 on Are smart phones making us smarter?
- Yes, social media companies should crack down on white supremacistsPosition 1 on Should social media companies crack down on white supremacists?
- Yes, social media is being used to target the disenfranchised in swing statesPosition 1 on Is social media being used to target the disenfranchised in swing states?Social media is being used to target the disenfranchised in swing states. Polarising content is being used for voter suppression and foreign states are influencing the 2020 election.
- Yes, social media should be banned in schoolsPosition 1 on Should social media be banned in schools?
- Yes, social networking sites are good for societyPosition 1 on Are social networking sites good for society?Social networking sites have ushered in a new form of communication. We now have easy access to individuals, organisations and events which benefits us in many instances, such as when job-hunting and simply keeping up with current affairs.
- Yes, socialism is ethical and advantageousPosition 1 on Is socialism ethical?This position holds that socialism is both ethical and advantageous. It argues socialism is the only feasible route to a fair society, since its central aim is to build a community founded on equality and broadly shared prosperity.