Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Is theocracy good?
Position‹3 of 3

Theocracies can be implemented in different ways

This position holds that theocracy is not inherently good or bad — what matters is how it is implemented. It argues that there are different degrees of theocracy, that many states are quasi-theocratic without admitting it, and that the problem lies in execution rather than the principle.

Supporting arguments · 5

  1. Many countries are quasi-theocracies but claim not to be
    There are theocracies around the world, but many do not acknowledge that they are theocracies.
  2. There are different levels of theocracy
    Theocracies are not an all or nothing thing – there is a gradient of religious influence across different countries.
  3. The issue is with how theocracies are carried out
    The problem with many theocracies is the way government or leadership is imposed on populations, not the idea of theocracy itself.
  4. The alternatives to theocracy around the world don't work
    While there are many systems of governing aside from theocracies, they are not preferrable.
  5. Theocracies are fine as long as it is my religion
    There is nothing wrong with a theocracy - as long as it is the right religion.