Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Do films and TV series glamourize crime?
Position‹2 of 3›
No, films and series do not glamourize crime.
Argument1 of 2›

The Godfather Effect

The Godfather trilogy changed the way Italian-Americans saw themselves because they were the first films that didn't portray Italian stereotypes.

The argument

“The Godfather Effect” is a study of the trilogy by Tom Santopietro which shows that the Italian characters in the films were portrayed as real human beings instead of stereotypical caricatures who spoke with heavy accents. This had a positive effect on the American culture which had considered the Italian immigrant as "the other".

Premises

[P1]The Godfather trilogy portrayed Italian characters as fully realized human beings rather than stereotypical caricatures. [P2] This humanizing portrayal positively shifted American culture's perception of Italian immigrants, who had previously been treated as 'the other'. [C] Therefore, films like The Godfather do not glamourize crime but instead produce meaningful cultural and humanizing effects.

Counter-arguments

The film and its sequels are most famously remembered for romanticizing a mafia family and their crimes to stay in power. Even though the characters are realistic, the trilogy still reinforced the stereotype about Italians being likely involved in mafia affairs.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] The trilogy reinforced the stereotype about Italians being often involved in mafia affairs. The first film was boycotted by the mafia in NYC until the producer made an economic agreement.

Further reading

John Patterson explains how the mafia tried to shut down the filming of The Godfather 'The Godfather Effect' by Tom Santopietro By Daniel Bubbeo The Godfather Effect: Changing Hollywood, America, and Me