Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Should UK students be charged university fees?
Position1 of 2
No, the UK should make higher education free for students.
Argument2 of 4

Higher education fees leave students with psychological burden

Charging students high fees can severely impact their mental health.

The argument

Even though the current system effectively means that those who earn below £21,000 will not have to pay back their student loan, simply the thought of such a crushing debt can be problematic. For those who have to borrow the entire sum of their fees, and whose parents cannot contribute financially, such a debt burden in itself is problematic. There are frequent reports of students who have claimed that the quantity of money they owed deepened their mental health issues.

Context

In recent years there has been a push to improve not only people's physical health, but also their mental health. Increasingly, studies suggest that our financial health can have a big impact on our mental health; as those with the least money report more feelings of anxiety and depression If debt can lead to psychological problems, then fees may not only harm student's opportunities but also their health.

Premises

[P1]Even though UK graduates earning below £21,000 need not repay their loans, the mere thought of such crushing debt can be problematic. [P2] For those who must borrow their full fees without family support the debt burden is worse, and there are frequent reports of students saying the sums they owed deepened their mental-health issues. [C] Therefore, because higher-education fees leave students with a psychological burden, the UK should make higher education free.

Counter-arguments

Whilst debt and depression are linked, often depression can lead to an accumulation of debt from poor decision-making [

Rejecting the premises

If premise one is false, in that depression causes debt rather than vice versa, then this could be disproved.