Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Can all philosophy questions be answered?
Position1 of 2
Yes, all philosophy questions can be answered.
Argument1 of 2

Philosophy is an academic study made for everyone to understand wholly

Academic versions of different fields of study is meant to help people understand it better. People go to primary school, secondary school, and college to learn about these subjects. Philosophy, in academic form, can be understood by everyone.

The argument

Academic studies are a great way to learn something new, and the claim here rests on what formal teaching does to a body of knowledge before anyone encounters it. Young children learn the basics of math, science, and history. In college, adults learn about things to help them get a specific career. Because the studies they're learning are so broad, learning it as an academic study makes it easier to understand: the subject arrives already sorted, sequenced and reduced to what a newcomer needs, rather than as an undifferentiated mass they must organise for themselves. The classroom is where that sorting happens. In the classroom, teachers must teach individuals what they've learned in their career. The teachers were taught in the same manner, so each generation passes on a version of the subject that has already been through the same filtering more than once. When a study is made into a class, its more condensed and important information is presented to the students in an easy-to-understand way — a process indifferent to the subject matter, applying to philosophy exactly as it applies to mathematics or history. Because philosophy is an academic study, it also becomes easier to understand. The consequence, on this argument, is a steadily growing pool of people equipped to work on the subject's questions. Once students master philosophy in school, they'll become philosophical experts in no time. If philosophy wasn't an academic study, then people wouldn't be able to understand it, and when people can't understand something, they will have questions about it that go unanswered. But, condensing philosophy can provide answers to all its questions, because the more people who understand it, the more number of questions will find answers.

Context

Academic studies are used to help people understand how the world and society works. Science became an academic study when William Whewell wrote “History of the Inductive Sciences” in 1837. Philosophy on the other hand has been very dynamic throughout history. It’s constantly refined to be available for students.

Premises

[P1]Turning a subject into an academic study condenses it and presents its important information in an easy-to-understand way. [P2] Because philosophy is taught as an academic study, it too becomes easier for more people to understand. [P3] The more people who understand philosophy, the more of its questions will find answers. [C] Therefore, philosophy is an academic study made for everyone to understand wholly, so all its questions can be answered.

Counter-arguments

Academic studies were made for students to learn about the field of study they emulate. However, not everyone can learn these academic studies. In fact, students struggle in different academic studies every semester. Students must get tutors and extra help to study for topics that they’re not good in. Philosophy is no different. The academic study of philosophy is condensed so that students can understand it. However, it doesn’t mean everyone is guaranteed to understand it. Philosophy has hard concepts to understand. It’s just like any other topic of study. Even condensed philosophy has questions that won’t be answered. Questions such as “What is the meaning of life?” or “Does reality extend into other dimensions?”. They’re in a philosophy class. But they can’t be universally answered. Philosophy doesn’t have these answers.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] Not everyone can understand academic topics. [Rejecting P2] Philosophy is hard for some people to understand. [Rejecting P3] Not all philosophical questions can be answered.