Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
How do we think about the snowflake generation?
Position1 of 4
The term "snowflake" is a politicized insult
Argument

The term “snowflake” is a politicized insult from the right targeted at the left

Whether the snowflake generation exists or not, it is undeniable that the rise of this terminology came in time with the resurgence of conservatism in the United States and Great Britain.

The argument

The term “snowflake” is one that is used in a derogatory manner to describe millennials and students alleged to be overly sensitive and underly interested in differing opinions. Whether the snowflake generation exists or not, it is undeniable that the rise of this terminology came in time with the resurgence of conservatism in the United States and Great Britain. This rise is characterized by the election of Donald Trump and the referendum in favor of Brexit. From this root, “snowflake” became a term used by politicians on the right to target liberals of the left, criticizing liberals, particularly the young, in one fell swoop. This insult falls in line with the right's interpretation of the left as a sensitive group, constantly concerned about safe spaces, trigger warnings, and political correctness.

Premises

[P1]The term "snowflake" emerged and gained popularity alongside the resurgence of right-wing politics marked by Trump's election and Brexit. [P2] The term has been wielded primarily by right-wing politicians to deride young liberals as overly sensitive about safe spaces, trigger warnings, and political correctness. [C] Therefore, "snowflake" is best understood as a politicized insult from the right aimed at the left rather than a neutral descriptor.

Counter-arguments

Generally, the term “snowflake” as an insult does not fall along political lines, but along lines of age. For example, in Britain regarding the EU referendum, “snowflake” as a term became popularized by the older generation commenting on the “hysterical” reaction of the younger one. Boomers and other older generations interpret the current generation of young people as soft, but it does not always come with political connotations.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P2] The counter reads the line of attack as generational rather than partisan: in Britain around the EU referendum the term was popularised by older people characterising the younger generation's reaction as hysterical, and the charge that the young are soft does not always carry political content. [Rejecting C] On that reading the word is not best understood as a right-to-left insult, since the division it marks runs between age groups and can be used without reference to the political positions the argument places at its centre.