- Question
In 'Lord of the Flies', is Jack evil?
In Nobel Prize-winner William Golding’s 1954 dystopian novel Lord of the Flies, a group of British schoolboys are stranded on an deserted island and are left to govern themselves. This ill-fated attempt to battle through civilization, morality, and order led to extreme bloodlust, violence, and savagery amongst the group of boys. Jack Merridew, the power-loving antagonist of the story is obsessed with dominance over the group since the beginning of the novel. But despite Jack’s antagonistic nature and selfishness, he may not be malicious.
Jack is evil in Lord of the Flies
Jack is naturally evil-minded, and the conflict on the island only heightened his animalistic nature. His personality is rooted in exerting dominance and control over others.
Jack is not evil in Lord of the Flies
This position holds that Jack in Lord of the Flies is not truly evil. It argues that his behaviour is a reaction to extreme circumstances — frustration at being passed over for Ralph's leadership, and a savagery born of the psychological strain of trying to survive while stranded.