- Question
What is the purpose of prisons?
Is the point of prisons to restrict freedom as punishment for crimes committed? Should prisons be rehabilitative? Are prisoners supposed to emerge from the experience deterred from committing future crimes and morphed into law-abiding citizens?
The purpose of prison is retribution
This position holds that the purpose of prison is retribution. It argues incarceration should be an unpleasant experience that makes offenders pay for the harm they have caused, delivering justice to victims by ensuring wrongdoing meets a fitting penalty.
The purpose of prison is rehabilitation
This position holds that the purpose of prison is rehabilitation. It argues that prisoners deserve second chances and should be prepared for return to society, that the system must address the root causes of crime, and that this serves everyone — especially minorities harmed most by incarceration.
The purpose of prison is incapacitation
This position holds that the purpose of prison is incapacitation. It argues that prisons exist to restrict the freedom of dangerous people, protecting society by physically preventing known criminals from committing further crimes while they are locked safely away.
The purpose of prison is deterrence
This position holds that the purpose of prison is deterrence. It argues that the prospect of imprisonment stops people from committing crimes in the first place — that fear of the consequences keeps would-be offenders in check, preventing crime before it happens.