- Question
Should we mute the microphones, find a better referee, or cancel them altogether?
After chaotic televised debates, this entry maps proposals for fixing them — setting out the positions that candidates' microphones should be muted, that a better moderator is the answer, and that microphones should be cut altogether.
We should mute microphones
Proponents of this position hold that selective muting is the minimal fix: leaving audible only the speaker whose turn it is enforces turn taking automatically, without altering the occasion or depending on a moderator's nerve.
We should find a better referee
This position holds that the format is sound and the enforcement is not: a moderator with the standing and the will to hold speakers to their time and their question would prevent the breakdown, so the fix is officiating rather than machinery.
We should cancel microphones altogether
Proponents of this position hold that amplification is itself the mechanism of disruption: while everyone is always audible, interrupting pays. Removing the microphones removes the reward, so whoever is not speaking cannot talk over whoever is.