Is the United States exceptional?

American history is distinct from the rest of the world's

Question: Is the United States exceptional?
Position‹2 of 3›: Yes, America is exceptional
Argument1 of 3›: American history is distinct from the rest of the world's

The way that America's history has unfolded means that it is clearly distinct from other nations.

The argument

American history is different from that of other nations because its revolution is exceptional. The United States was the first nation to be built on popular sovereignty and the first to not frame its national identity in a celebration of monarchical or aristocratic authority. Rather, the United States was founded on the natural rights of the individual and a patriotism based on belief in ones fellow man.

Premises

[P1]America's founding was unlike other nations': it was the first nation built on popular sovereignty rather than a celebration of monarchical or aristocratic authority. [P2] It was founded on the natural rights of the individual and a patriotism rooted in belief in one's fellow man. [C] Therefore, because its history is distinct from the rest of the world's, the United States is exceptional.

Counter-arguments

The United States is not the only nation that defined itself as Republican even in the eighteenth century. For instance, the Netherlands or Italian city-states.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] This conception of what nations can be founded on is not unique to the US.