Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Is direct democracy superior to representative democracy?
Position2 of 2
No, representative democracy is better
Argument3 of 3

Direct democracy needs too much public education investment

Direct democracy places too much responsibility on individuals to understand complex policy issues.

The argument

Direct democracy requires substantial amounts of investment in public education. Not every citizen would be starting from the same knowledge base or have a similar desire to take on responsibility for the complex affairs of the state. In a modern state, with competing demands for public spending there is no guarantee that taxpayers would want to meet this heavy cost or that individuals would be willing to pay this personal price.

Premises

[P1]Direct democracy demands substantial investment in public education, since citizens do not start from the same knowledge base or share an equal willingness to take responsibility for the state's complex affairs. [P2] In a modern state with competing demands for spending, there is no guarantee taxpayers would meet this heavy cost or that individuals would pay the personal price required. [C] Therefore, because direct democracy needs too much public-education investment, representative democracy is better.

Counter-arguments

In a direct democracy the affairs of the state are the responsibility of every citizen. They cannot leave them to elected representatives or economic elites. This ensures that every citizen has the incentive to participate and it encourages the state to make sure that every voter has a high level of education of public policy so they can properly dispense their duty. A consequence of this is that it ensures that citizens have a higher level of ownership of the policy decisions made compared to their counterparts in other states, and a civic responsibility to their fellow countrymen with whom under this system they are forced to cooperate.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P2] This use of resources is worth it to have an engaged electorate.