Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Is a hotdog a sandwich?
Position2 of 2
No, a hotdog is not a sandwich
Argument1 of 2

A sandwich requires two pieces of bread

By definition, a sandwich requires two pieces of bread to be present with some sort of food in the middle. A hotdog is only one piece of bread with food in the middle, so it cannot qualify as a sandwich.

The argument

A food item requires two pieces of bread in order to qualify in the category of "sandwich". This is according to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, a hot dog is one piece of bread with meat and fillings inside. The mere fact that a single piece of bread has a unique shape does not make it a sandwich. A piece of toast with toppings would not be considered a sandwich, because it is a single piece of bread. A hot dog is the same thing, just with a specially shaped piece of bread. In fact, the definition of a hot dog in the dictionary is "a frankfurter with a typically mild flavor that is heated and usually served in a long split roll". This includes no mention of the multiple pieces of bread required for classification as a sandwich and does not even necessitate the use of bread at all as a critical part of designation as a hot dog. Thus, by nature, a hot dog would not qualify as a sandwich. Its own definition does not allow it to fall under that category and it should not be attempted to be placed there.

Premises

[P1]By the Merriam-Webster definition, a sandwich requires two pieces of bread. [P2] A hot dog uses only a single split roll, much as a piece of toast with toppings is not a sandwich despite its toppings. [P3] The dictionary definition of a hot dog mentions only a frankfurter in a split roll, with no requirement of two pieces of bread. [C] Therefore, because a sandwich requires two pieces of bread, a hotdog is not a sandwich.

Counter-arguments

Although the hot dog definition may not classify it as a sandwich, the definition of a sandwich certainly does. By definition of the dictionary, a sandwich considers a split bun with filling as a form of sandwich. It's a rectangle/square situation, but it still allows hot dogs to be classified as sandwiches.

Rejecting the premises

The standard home chip or noodle sandwich involves folding a single slice of bread in half.