Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question

Is Donald Trump mentally ill?

To some, Donald Trump is a rambling buffoon. To others, he is a voice of truth in a political quagmire of lies and deceit. But are his erratic mind, eccentric way of speaking and short attention span indicators of an underlying mental illness affecting the US president?

Position 1 of 3
Read this position →

Yes, Donald Trump is mentally ill

This position holds that Donald Trump is mentally ill. It points to the concerns voiced by mental-health experts, to what it reads as signs of illness in his speech and behaviour, and to claims by people close to him that he is mentally unstable.

Position 2 of 3
Read this position →

No, Donald Trump is not mentally ill

This position holds that Donald Trump is not mentally ill. It argues his unconventional manner simply differs from other politicians, that someone mentally ill could not have reached his position, that his style reflects his reality-TV background, and that his medical exam found no illness.

Position 3 of 3
Read this position →

It is impossible to say if Trump is mentally ill

This position holds that it is impossible to say whether Donald Trump is mentally ill. It argues that no genuine diagnosis can be made from public appearances alone — that the disorders attributed to him are not clear-cut, and ethical practice forbids diagnosing a person at a distance.