- Question
What is the Mind-Body problem?
What is the mind? Since the beginning of civilization, we have grappled with the idea of consciousness. Could the study of our brain and nervous system account for conscious thought? If not, what are the relationships between the non-physical processes and the physical ones?
Mind-Body Problem: Dualism
This position presents the dualist answer to the mind-body problem: that a person is made of two distinct parts, a physical body and a non-physical mind. It draws on the knowledge argument about qualia, first-person authority over one's experience, and the existence of free will.
Mind-Body Problem: Idealism
This position presents the idealist answer to the mind-body problem: that only the mind truly exists, and the physical world we perceive is a composition of mental experience. It draws on cases such as hemiplegic stroke victims to argue for the primacy of mind over matter.
Mind-Body Problem: Materialism
This position presents the materialist answer to the mind-body problem: that humans are purely physical matter, mind included. It argues physical explanation is simplest (Occam's razor), that mental states arose through physical evolution, and that beliefs reduce to physical experience.
Mind-Body problem: functionalism
This position presents functionalism as an answer to the mind-body problem. It holds that mental states can be reduced to functional responses to stimuli—Putnam likened the mind and body to a computer—offering an alternative to the perceived weaknesses of materialism.