Home Categories About
argument top image
Did Jack really have to die to save Rose at the end of Titanic? Did Jack really have to die to save Rose at the end of Titanic?
Yes, Jack had to die to save Rose in the Titanic Yes, Jack had to die to save Rose in the Titanic
No, Jack did not have to die to save Rose in the Titanic No, Jack did not have to die to save Rose in the Titanic
Jack's death was a necessary artistic choice Jack's death was a necessary artistic choice
Jack would have died of hypothermia before implementing any solution Jack would have died of hypothermia before implementing any solution
The door would sink under the weight of 2 people The door would sink under the weight of 2 people
The stressful situation meant that they couldn't think of a solution The stressful situation meant that they couldn't think of a solution
The door was big enough for 2 people The door was big enough for 2 people
Rose could have given him her lifejacket Rose could have given him her lifejacket
The door would hold both of them if they tied a life jacket to the bottom The door would hold both of them if they tied a life jacket to the bottom
Debate Mini Map

Did Jack really have to die to save Rose at the end of Titanic?
Back to question

No, Jack did not have to die to save Rose in the Titanic

< (2 of 2)

The door would hold both of them if they tied a life jacket to the bottom

< (3 of 3)

The Argument

Discovery Channel's TV show 'MythBusters' discovered that it would possible for both Jack and Rose to survive on the door if they tied a life jacket underneath to make it more buoyant. [1]

Counter arguments

Premises

Rejecting the premises

References

  1. https://www.newsweek.com/titanic-movie-anniversary-could-jack-have-survived-scientists-weigh-751758

In the Wild

This page was last edited on Thursday, 12 Nov 2020 at 00:24 UTC

Explore related arguments