argument top image

Who is the best basketball player of all time?
Back to question

James has won consistently even as the game changes

As other superstars have risen and fallen, and the game has been revolutionized by new statistics and strategies, James's success has been the only constant.
< (2 of 2) Next argument >

The Argument

No NBA superstar has faced competition as strong and varied as LeBron James, and he has managed to lead his teams to an extraordinary amount of success despite this exceptional level of opposition. James won his first NBA championship in 2012, defeating an Oklahoma City Thunder team that included three players who would eventually win the NBA's overall Most Valuable Player (MVP) award: Kevin Durant, Russell Westbrook, and James Harden. In three of James's first five NBA finals series (2007 and 2011-2014), his teams faced off against San Antonio Spurs teams led by Tim Duncan and coached by Gregg Popovich. The Duncan-Popovich Spurs teams are widely considered one of the NBA's great dynasties, and the two ultimately won five NBA titles together. James's next four finals series (2015-2018) were contested against another great NBA dynasty, the Stephen Curry-led Golden State Warriors, which set numerous records including the all time record for most wins in a season in 2016, when they won 73 of 82 games. That same year, the Warriors were prevented from achieving the most successful season ever by James's Cleveland Cavaliers, which defeated the record-setting Warriors 4-3 in the NBA finals. The Cavaliers's victory brought the franchise its first ever NBA championship, and James was named the finals MVP. Complicating the NBA's landscape even further, the timeline of James's career has been concurrent with the development of radical new insights and strategies, driven largely by an explosion of advanced statistical methods. The influential Sloan Sports Analytics Conference was first held in 2006, just a few years into James's NBA career. As teams have developed more and more sophisticated methods of analyzing play, players have been forced to contend with unexpected challenges and innovative new tactics. In particular, the newly emphasized strategic value of three-point shots in the NBA has caused a dramatic shift in play styles, owing in part to the meteoric rise of three-point specialists such as James's rival superstar, Stephen Curry. Amidst all this rapid change, James has somehow managed to set a modern standard for consistency, reaching eight consecutive NBA finals series from 2011-2018. No player since the NBA's merger with the ABA in 1976 has reached the finals so consistently, and James did so even in an era of rapid evolution for the sport of basketball.

Counter arguments


[P1] Basketball has changed immensely over the years. [P2] However, James' performance has remained constant. [P3] This makes him the greatest player of all time.

Rejecting the premises


This page was last edited on Friday, 17 Apr 2020 at 12:05 UTC

Explore related arguments