argument top image

How will coronavirus affect religion?
Back to question

Religious leaders are pushing bogus remedies

False cures promoted by religious leaders will lead to a lack of trust in religion.
Coronavirus Health Religion


The growth in false 'cures' promulgated by religious leaders worldwide will destroy the trust people have in their faith. The examples of this dangerous practice are everywhere. In Iran, pilgrims were encouraged to lick Shiite Muslim shrines to protect themselves from infection. In Myanmar, an exulted Buddhist monk claimed that ingesting three palm seeds and a lime would grant immunity. Meanwhile, in Argentina, the well-known pastor Héctor Aníbal Giménez exploited the virus. Encouraged by wanton greed, Giménez sold bottles of hand sanitiser at premium prices. He told his 30,000 followers that using the gel would immunise them against the virus.[1]. These false claims could have potentially lethal consequences.

The Argument

Believers place their trust in religious leaders. Those people are meant to act as their spiritual guides and create a stronger connection between the believer and their philosophy. This relationship depends on trust. The rising number of these leaders - across all religions - touting false remedies is eroding this trust. In many cases, without it, there is very little to keep the believer in the faith. In one shocking case, the Texan TV preacher Kenneth Copeland used a fake cure to boost his ratings. The televangelist claimed he had healed viewers through his sermon, asking them to touch their TV screens for immunisation.[2]. As these scandals come to light and the credibility of these leaders is damaged, so is the belief of their followers.

Counter arguments

These examples are outliers, and do not represent a trend amongst religious leaders. Religion, like any sector, will always be wracked with scandals. Such is the nature of any group of scale. A small number of crackpot examples cannot speak to the wider group.



[P1] Belief depends on trust between leader and follower [P2] Leaders are touting false information [P3] Followers lose trust in leaders

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] Belief does not depend on trust between leader and follower


This page was last edited on Monday, 26 Oct 2020 at 14:48 UTC

Explore related arguments