Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question

How does coronavirus compare to other pandemics?

COVID-19 has been devastating, affecting people across the world and killing thousands. However, it is far from the first pandemic of its kind. From the Spanish flu to the bubonic plague, throughout history pandemics have killed huge amounts of the population. Is the coronavirus pandemic the worst in history? Or have previous pandemics been worse?

Position 1 of 6
Read this position →

COVID-19 is the worst pandemic in history

This position holds that Covid-19 is the worst pandemic in history. It argues that no previous outbreak has had so devastating a global effect, in part because modern globalisation and travel spread the disease around the world faster and more widely than ever before.

Position 2 of 6
Read this position →

Spanish Influenza is the worst pandemic in history

This position holds that the Spanish Influenza was the worst pandemic in history. It points to the staggering death toll of the outbreak that followed the First World War, its unusual lethality among otherwise healthy young people, and the way wartime conditions accelerated its spread.

Position 3 of 6
Read this position →

The bubonic plague is the worst pandemic in history

This position holds that the bubonic plague was the worst pandemic in history. It argues the plague killed more people than any other outbreak, devastating medieval populations—and notes that, at the time, many even believed the disease to be a punishment sent from God.

Position 4 of 6
Read this position →

HIV/AIDS is the worst pandemic in history

This position holds that HIV/AIDS is the worst pandemic in history. It argues that governments' refusal to acknowledge the crisis and act allowed infection rates to soar, and that homophobia helped perpetuate the disease, ultimately costing millions of lives.

Position 5 of 6
Read this position →

Smallpox is the worst pandemic in history

This position holds that smallpox is the worst pandemic in history. It argues the disease was devastating for centuries—decimating the Native American population after European contact—before becoming, to date, the only human disease ever fully eradicated.

Position 6 of 6
Read this position →

The Plague of Justinian is the worst pandemic in history

This position holds that the Plague of Justinian was the worst pandemic in history. One of the earliest recorded, it argues the sixth-century outbreak killed 30–50 million people—the highest proportion of any pandemic—and helped bring about the fall of the Roman Empire.