Should human cloning be banned?

Human cloning is medically unsafe and unethical

Question: Should human cloning be banned?
Position1 of 2›: Yes, human cloning should be banned
Argument‹2 of 2: Human cloning is medically unsafe and unethical

Technology has only gone so far with animal cloning, which has proved to have slim chances of success and can be seen as unethical. Science and medicine are not advanced enough to clone humans. Going a step further with humans would prove dangerous to the human being cloned.

The argument

When it comes to cloning animals, it has been proven that "only a small percentage of attempts are successful” and “many of the clones die during gestation, even in late stages.” It’s also reported that “newborn clones are often abnormal; and that the procedures may carry serious risks for the mother." Nearly 90 percent of clones fail to develop into liveborn animals. Among those that are born into the world alive, a huge number have serious or fatal medical problems. The famous cloning case of the sheep, Dolly, proved to be the most successful cloning. Dolly was born from cloning and lived until she was six years old. Unfortunately, she developed a lung disease and severe arthritis and had to be euthanized. A typical life expectancy of a sheep is 10-12 years. While Dolly lived longer than anyone expected, she was still subjected to a fatal disease that left her suffering and being euthanized all in the name of science. Subjecting a human to a similar fate while knowing the risk and outcomes is unethical. Cloning does not guarantee the survival and safety of the individual.

Premises

[P1]Nearly 90% of animal clones fail to develop into liveborn animals, and many born alive have serious or fatal medical problems. [P2] Even Dolly, the most successful clone, developed fatal disease and had to be euthanised well short of a sheep's normal lifespan. [P3] Subjecting a human to the same risks, knowing the outcomes, is unethical, since cloning cannot guarantee the individual's survival and safety. [C] Therefore, because human cloning is medically unsafe and unethical, human cloning should be banned.

Counter-arguments

In the end, cloning was proved successful through the creation of Dolly. Dolly lived longer than any scientist expected and even successfully had offspring of her own, where they lived into adulthood.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] Through trial and error, cloning could prove to be successful and a futuristic way to start a family.