It depends on the type of love
<
(6 of 6)
The seven types of love
The ancient Greeks had names for the seven different types of love.
<
(2 of 4)
Next argument >
Context
The ancient Greeks were far more precise in their definition of love. This was reflected in their language.
The Argument
Eros is the type of love that involves a passionate, intense desire for something or someone. We might refer to this love as attraction. It does not necessarily have to be reciprocal. We simply desire something for what it is and the esteem in which we hold it.
Philia, unlike Eros, is more of a fondness and appreciation for something. It is not as intense a desire as Eros and does not have to be romantic or sexual. Philia might be the type of love we hold for our family or our boss or even our job.
Agape refers to the brotherly or paternal love for humanity. In ancient Greece, it was the love that God feels for humanity. It can also be extended to mean the paternal, unconditional love that transcends all earthly and mortal bounds.[1]
Storge applies to the affection and caring love you have for your family. Philautia is the love of oneself. Ludus is the playful love children experiences, and finally, Pragma is the long-standing love of a couple that has been together for many years.[2]
Counter arguments
Not all of these are really love. Some conflate enjoyment for love. For example, philia is a fondness and appreciation for a person or object. This is not the same as love. Unlike other definition's of love, Plato's is too wide in its scope. It includes feelings that would be better ascribed to enjoyment, appreciation and fondness.
Proponents
Premises
[P1] There are seven different types of love.
[P2] Each has its own unique properties and characteristics.
Rejecting the premises
[Rejecting P1] This wide definition includes enjoyment and fondness, which are not love.