Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Should Donald Trump or Joe Biden win the 2020 US Presidential Election?
Position1 of 2
Joe Biden should be elected in the 2020 US election
Argument1 of 14

Joe Biden will fight for women's equality

Biden will enforce wage gap transparency and accountability as one of his many pledges to end gender income equality. He also has plans to widen female representation public life and reduce systemic inequalities.

The argument

During his time as Vice President, Joe Biden has proved that he will be an advocate for women's equality and promote policy for women's rights. During his tenure as Vice President to Barack Obama from 2008-2016, Biden helped draft multiple women's anti-violence acts and fair pay acts to increase women's equality. Outside of his political life, Joe Biden has a reputation amongst his female staff of treating them equitably with men. Biden ensures women are receiving equal pay and befits and gives women equal opportunities for growth and support within his campaign. Importantly, Joe Biden also selected a woman, Kamala Harris, to run with him as Vice President. Biden has also made it clear that increasing women's equity and equality will be a goal of his if he wins the 2020 US Presidential Election. Biden pledged to increase affordable child care and paid parental leave options. Biden has also pledged to end violence against women in the United States and abroad. Joe Biden should be elected the next President of the United States because women make up 50% of the United States population, and he will help them live better lives and gain the rights they deserve,

Premises

[P1]As Vice President, Biden helped draft women's anti-violence and fair-pay acts, and he has a reputation for treating female staff equitably and selecting a woman, Kamala Harris, as his running mate. [P2] He has pledged to expand affordable child care and paid parental leave and to end violence against women at home and abroad, and women make up half the US population. [C] Because Joe Biden will fight for women's equality, he should be elected in the 2020 US election.

Counter-arguments

In recent years, many women have come forward accusing Joe Biden of inappropriate conduct and behavior spanning back almost 30 years. Furthermore, in an important sexual assault case in the 1990s, Joe Biden failed to call on key witnesses for the woman on the stand and allowed men to harass and berate her with questions. Joe Biden's women's agenda is only present on his campaign to appease women and save face. Joe Biden's campaign will not follow through on the promises he is making to women. He has treated them without respect in the past and will continue to do so.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] Legislative involvement and staffing practice are indirect evidence about a future record. Bills drafted as one participant among many, and the internal practice of a campaign, do not establish what an administration would prioritise, and a running-mate selection is a single appointment that the premise treats as demonstrating a settled disposition. [Rejecting P2] Pledges state intent, and the premise does not address what lies between intent and outcome: child care and paid leave require legislation a president cannot supply alone. The closing step is also a non sequitur — that women are half the population establishes how many people are affected, not that this candidate would improve their position, and the position requires a comparison with the alternative that the argument never makes.