Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
What is the best system of government?
Position3 of 3
Absolute Monarchy
Argument1 of 2

Quick passing of laws

Since there is only one ruler in an absolute monarchy, laws are passed very quickly.

The argument

Absolute monarchies pass laws quickly. Other governments, like America’s democratic republic system, must go through many steps to pass a law with no guarantee that it will be passed at all. The faster a law is passed, the quicker people will adjust to it.

Premises

[P1]Absolute monarchies can pass laws quickly, whereas systems like America's democratic republic must go through many steps with no guarantee a law passes at all. [P2] The faster a law is passed, the quicker people can adjust to it. [C] Therefore, because it allows the quick passing of laws, absolute monarchy is the best system of government.

Counter-arguments

It is very foolish to have laws pass quickly through one ruler. One of the reasons the French Revolution happened was because the finances of the country was going towards people of higher class. The monarchs didn’t try to help peasants and the middle class. If the ruler is corrupt, they can pass laws that benefit themselves and not the civilians of the country.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] Dictatorships pass laws quickly like monarchies. [Rejecting P3] Passing laws too quickly would harm the country. [Rejecting P3] An absolute monarchy only has one ruler, meaning they rely on themselves to make laws. If they aren’t knowledgeable about how to run a country or they are corrupt, the country falls.