Encyclopedia of Opinion
Question
Which books should you read while self-isolating from coronavirus?
Position2 of 6
Self-help
Argument3 of 4

The Power of Now

Eckhart Toll's guide to living in the moment shares many characteristics with practising mindfulness - or shedding anxieties to embrace the present.

The argument

You should read The Power of Now by Eckhart Tolle while self-isolating from the coronavirus because it gives practical application for how to manage your mental health. This is incredibly relevant because mental health concerns have grown as a result of the coronavirus. The Power of Now discusses tactics to help you take control of your mental health and thinking. Therefore, it could help ease some of the frustrations and anxieties that you may have due to the pandemic. This book is important to read because it provides a source of spiritual guidance during the pandemic. As the coronavirus has forced people into self-isolation, many are suffering both mentally and spiritually. People are in need of joy and comfort in times of uncertainty. The Power of Now discusses ways in which people can improve their spiritual well being. The Power of Now teaches important principles of living in the moment. It guides the reader to a mindful transformation that leads to a more enlightened mindset. This mindset can be applied to the anxieties and uncertainties surrounding the pandemic. This new way of thinking allows the reader to accept what they cannot change. This is an important practice to learn and apply while self-isolating.

Premises

[P1]The Power of Now offers practical tactics for managing mental health, highly relevant as pandemic anxieties have grown. [P2] It provides spiritual guidance for people suffering in self-isolation. [P3] Its principles of living in the moment help readers accept what they cannot change. [C] Therefore, The Power of Now is a valuable self-help book to read while self-isolating.

Counter-arguments

All people do not believe in ways to spiritually improve and become enlightened. They may instead be more responsive to self-help books that have concrete ways to improve their physical health or financial status. In addition, rather than wanting to improve themselves, a person may desire to distract themselves from the pandemic. The Power of Now encourages readers to reflect on their current situation during the pandemic, which may cause more anxiety for them.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] What the book offers is a contemplative practice presented in spiritual terms rather than a set of clinical techniques, and the premise does not distinguish the two. Nothing is cited on outcomes, and popularity is not evidence of efficacy. [Rejecting P2] The counter-argument on record notes that the spiritual framing is a limitation as well as a feature: readers who do not share those premises are unlikely to find guidance in them, and may be better served by self-help addressed to health, work or finances. [Rejecting P3] The recommendation may be counterproductive for its stated audience. The counter argues that turning attention inward toward one's present circumstances can heighten rather than relieve anxiety for someone already distressed by isolation, and that many readers want distraction rather than reflection. [Rejecting C] The argument also does not compete on its own question. The competing positions offer fiction, biography and current affairs, and no reason is given why self-help — let alone this title — is the better use of the time.