Who is the best BTS member?

Encyclopedia of Opinion

Question: Who is the best BTS member?
Position‹2 of 8›: Jimin is the best BTS member
Argument: Jimin is the best dancer in BTS

As BTS' main dancer, Jimin is immensely talented. Jimin's movements on stage are so powerful that they tell a story all on their own. Jimin is the best BTS member because of his extraordinary talent at choreography and dance.

The argument

Jimin is an extremely gifted dancer. The mere fact that he was chosen to be one of the group's main dancers is a testament to his ability. Jimin is one of the only BTS dancers with formal training; he studied modern dance in high school and came first in his class. Jimin is the best BTS boy because of his extraordinary talent.

Premises

[P1]Jimin is a gifted dancer, chosen as one of the group's main dancers. [P2] He is one of the only BTS members with formal training, having studied modern dance and come first in his high school class. [C] Therefore, because Jimin is the best dancer in BTS, he is the best BTS member.

Counter-arguments

Dancing talent is not the only factor that determines whether an idol is the best member of a K-Pop group. In addition, Jimin is also not the only BTS member known for his dance skills, and he has never won an award for his dancing, unlike J-Hope. It is debatable that Jimin is the best dancer, which then makes it doubtful that he is the best member of the group.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] Being assigned a role within a group reflects a production decision about how to distribute parts, which is not an independent verdict on ability. [Rejecting P2] Formal training is a fact about preparation rather than about result, and the premise leaves the conclusion unsupported twice over: other members are also known for their dancing and one of them has been recognised with awards, and even the group's best dancer need not be its best member, since the question turns on more than one skill.